Everyone seemed to like Boyer Station, WV in 05
Also, I'm friends w/ the owners of this place located near Cambridge, Ohio:
They have 3 big cabins, and 4 cottages [located along the treeline to lower left in the pic.] that can house 52 people.
A large area to camp in the middle and behind the cabins in the pic above.
It borders Salt Fork Lake/State park, which has a lodge and restaurant.
I went to a party there, and they had a guy come in and prepare a meal.
I'd be willing to help organize, if this place was chosen....