I would pick the F800 better off road, the tiger is a better street bike because of the 3 cylinder, but not as good off road because of the 3 cylinders. I ride the road to get off road. Also warranty 3 years for the BMW and a year for the tiger.
Our famous last words "It doesn't look too bad".
08 KTM 450 EXCR
2010 BMW F800GS