I really like my Rev'it Bastion GTX's. They are the best cold weather gloves that I have tried. I have some first gear ones and a set of snowmobile specific gloves that I used to use, but I haven't used either since I got the Bastion's. I also use heated grips. I use them Fall, Winter, and Spring.
They are a little big and bulky, but my hands stay dry and reasonably warm. I have worn them down under 25 degrees without problems. I have never had any problems pulling the lining out when I pull my hand out. I don't use them once the weather warms up past 60 or so. I will wear them in the mornings when it is cold out and switch to a warmer weather glove when it warms up in the afternoon.
2006 KTM 950 Adventure - Go Everywhere Bike
1993 Suzuki GSX1100G - Street Touring Shafty
2000 Suzuki DR200 - A Little Smaller