If you are liking the small towns, what about Young? Small, no meth, just south of the Rim, east of Roosevelt Lake, north of Glob (not a misspelling).
Fishing, mild weather, small town, close to bigger towns, PLENTY of trails...
The odds are good that the goods are odd
2013 Guzzi Stelvio (For Sale!!!)
2010 KTM 690 Enduro
2009 KTM 400XCW Plated