Connections are tight. I just fully charged the battery. Voltage read 14.25V. Tried to start and it just didn't have the cranking power. The battery voltage now reads 13.2V. I wasn't able to monitor the battery voltage when attempting to start since I couldn't hold the leads and start the bike at the same time, but I am guessing that the voltage is dropping really low when starting.
Bike is able to start with a boost and will run fine.
Looks like we're heading back down south to Reykjavik to look for a new battery. :( Could be worse.
This battery was fine until it got off the plane from New York. Could the cold during shipment have had any effect on the battery?