I have been wearing the Gaerne GX-1's for the past 2 years. These are far and away the most comfortable MX/Enduro style boots I have ever owned. For wide footed folks like me, the Gaerne's seem to always fit the best.
I just got back from a 6 day, 2,000 mile trip of 70% on road and 30% off, in warm, rainy, muddy and chilly conditions. They performed flawlessly. I was comfortable all day long, and while they are not technically waterproof, my feet never got wet.
I believe you can still find them around the $200 price point. For that price I can't believe there is a better option until you get to the $350 + price point, and even then I would be hard pressed to switch.
My favorite boots I've ever owned.
2004 KTM 950 Adventure
“A bore is someone who deprives you of solitude without providing you with company.”
― Oscar Wilde