Yes I am on ba.com also, ya know I was rear ended on my Speedmaster too! But bought a new one with the insurance money, I really enjoy it and will probably always have it. I don't know much about the Tiger's other than the motor is sweet and powerful, that being said I really don't like the bike too much (just personal preference) might feel different if I test rode one! But I am seriously thinking of adding a Buell Ulysses to the stable, somehow its calling my name, although the Versys is a close second, If you don't want a cruiser again, I would recommend a Versys, it also has a very nice twin engine. Good luck!
2007 Buell XB STT
2009 Kawasaki Versys (For Sale)
2008 Harley Fatbob
2007 Triumph Speedmaster
2006 Yamaha Road Star Warrior (Sold)
2004 Triumph Bonneville America (Sold)
2002 Suzuki Drz-400S